Solo 401k vs SEP IRA Calculator

Solo 401k vs SEP IRA for a Part-Time Side Hustle

Solo 401k vs SEP IRA for a part-time side hustle is one of those questions where the usual answer is right and also incomplete. The usual answer is the solo 401k, because its employee deferral lets you shelter far more on modest income. The incomplete part is the day job. Plenty of side hustlers already have a W-2 job with a 401k, and that changes the math completely.

Take a side business with $30,000 of net profit. Self-employment tax comes to about $4,239, and half of that, about $2,119, comes off to give net earnings near $27,900. A SEP IRA shelters about 20 percent of that figure, roughly $5,580. A solo 401k lets you defer up to $24,500 as the employee, which fits inside the $27,900 of net earnings, and then adds an employer piece on top. Same $30,000, and the solo plan shelters more than four times as much before the employer piece is even counted.

That gap is the whole reason the solo 401k exists for people like this. The SEP only contributes as the employer, so it scales with profit. The solo 401k contributes as employee and employer, and the employee part does not scale with profit at all. It is a flat amount up to the limit, which is why it wins so hard at low and middle incomes and why the two plans converge only at very high incomes, where both hit the $72,000 combined ceiling for 2026.

Now the day job twist. Your $24,500 deferral limit is one limit across every 401k you touch in a year. If your W-2 job already took $24,500 of deferrals, your solo 401k deferral room is zero. You can still make employer profit-sharing contributions to the solo plan, roughly 20 percent of net earnings for a sole proprietor, which lands near the SEP figure. In that case the solo plan loses its big advantage and the SEP starts looking sensible again, because it is simpler to run.

The SEP has two genuine advantages that have nothing to do with math. You can open one as late as your tax filing deadline, extensions included, and still count it for the prior year. And it has no annual filing like the solo 401k Form 5500-EZ, which kicks in once plan assets pass $250,000. If your side hustle earns $8,000 in a year and you are deciding in March, the SEP is the plan you can still open. The solo 401k window for that year closed on December 31.

When a solo 401k vs SEP IRA choice for a side hustle flips

The solo 401k also gives you a Roth deferral option and, if your plan document allows it, a loan option. The SEP gives you neither. Roth deferrals matter for side hustlers in a low tax year, say the first year of the business, when paying tax now looks cheap next to the rates you expect later. Loans matter less than people think, since borrowing from retirement should be a last resort, but having the option beats not having it.

Irregular income does not break either plan. Both let you contribute nothing in a bad year. The solo 401k only asks that the plan exist by December 31 if you want deferral room for that year, so an unpredictable December can leave you with a plan you barely fund. A SEP lets you wait until you see the final profit number, then decide. For a side hustle whose December income swings by thousands, that patience is a real feature.

My decision rule is blunt. Check your W-2 deferrals first. If you have deferral room left, open the solo 401k and use it. If your day job already maxed your deferrals, or your side income is small and you value simplicity over squeezing out the last dollar, take the SEP and spend the saved paperwork time on the business itself. One question I will leave open, because it depends on facts I do not have for you: will this side hustle hire anyone in the next two years? If yes, the solo plan stops fitting the moment an eligible employee arrives, and starting with a plan built for staff saves a conversion later.

Try it. Run your own numbers before you decide. Try the free solo 401k vs SEP IRA calculator

Frequently asked questions

Can I open a solo 401k for a side hustle if I already have a W-2 job?

Yes, but your employee deferral limit of $24,500 in 2026 is shared across all your 401k plans. If your day job plan already took the full deferral, your solo plan can only take employer profit sharing that year.

How much can a SEP IRA shelter on $30,000 of side income?

Roughly $5,600. A SEP for a sole proprietor works out to about 20 percent of net earnings after half the self-employment tax, and 20 percent of about $27,900 is $5,580.

Does a solo 401k have to be opened by December 31?

Yes for the deferral election. The plan must exist by December 31 of the tax year, even though employer contributions can wait until your filing deadline with extensions.

Can I skip contributions in a bad side hustle year?

Yes with either plan. Neither plan forces an annual contribution, so a $0 year costs you nothing except the lost shelter for that year.

Is a SEP IRA simpler for a small side hustle?

Yes. A SEP can be opened as late as your tax filing deadline with extensions, and it has no Form 5500-EZ filing. That simplicity is worth real money in saved hassle if your side income is small.

Related: Solo 401k Limits When You Also Have a W-2 Job · How Much Can I Contribute on $50,000 Income? · Can I Contribute to Both in the Same Year?

One note a month: subscribe to the newsletter.