Solo 401k vs SEP IRA Calculator

Solo 401k vs SIMPLE IRA for Self Employed Workers

Most self employed people who ask about solo 401k vs SIMPLE IRA for self employed retirement saving already know the punchline. The solo 401k lets you save more. What they do not know is how much more, and whether the extra paperwork is worth it for their income level. For an owner-only business, my answer is usually the solo 401k, and the rest of this article is the evidence for that answer plus the cases where I would change my mind.

Start with the numbers, because everything else is commentary on them. In 2026, a solo 401k allows an employee deferral of $24,500, or $32,500 if you are 50 or older, and the combined limit with employer profit sharing is $72,000, or $80,000 at 50 plus. A SIMPLE IRA allows an employee deferral of $17,000, or $21,000 at 50 plus, plus an employer match of up to 3 percent of pay or a 2 percent nonelective contribution. The deferral gap alone is $7,500 a year. Over a decade of steady saving, that gap is $75,000 of contributions before any growth, and that is before the employer side of the solo 401k even enters the picture.

Here is a worked example that shows why the structure matters more than the headline limit. Take a consultant with $120,000 of net self employment income. In a solo 401k, she defers $24,500 and adds roughly $22,000 of employer profit sharing, for about $46,500 total. In a SIMPLE IRA, she defers $17,000 and the business matches 3 percent, about $3,600, for about $20,600 total. Same income, same year, and the solo 401k shelters more than twice as much. The SIMPLE IRA is not a bad plan. It is a plan built for a different problem, namely a small employer who wants a simple plan for a handful of staff and is willing to accept a lower ceiling in exchange.

When solo 401k vs SIMPLE IRA for self employed savers comes down to employees

Employees are the real fork in the road. A solo 401k is only for an owner-only business, plus a spouse who works in it. Hire one eligible employee and the solo plan stops fitting. You convert to a regular 401k or pick another plan. A SIMPLE IRA, by contrast, is built for employers with up to 100 employees, and the employer contribution is mandatory in one of two forms: a dollar for dollar match up to 3 percent of pay, or a flat 2 percent for every eligible employee who earned at least $5,000. If you have staff, that mandatory piece is both the appeal and the cost. It is simple to explain to employees, and it is money out of your pocket every year whether business is good or not.

There is a second difference people underrate until tax season: the Roth option. A solo 401k lets you designate your employee deferrals as Roth, paying tax now and withdrawing qualified money tax free later. A SIMPLE IRA has no Roth version. That matters if you are in a low income year, maybe your first year freelancing, or a year between big contracts, and you expect higher rates later. It also matters for the backdoor Roth crowd, since SIMPLE IRA money sitting in a pre-tax account complicates Roth conversions through the pro-rata rule. The solo 401k keeps that door cleaner, provided you roll old pre-tax IRA money into it, which is a separate move worth checking before you convert anything.

Paperwork is where the SIMPLE IRA genuinely wins, and I will not pretend otherwise. A SIMPLE IRA has almost no annual filing. A solo 401k requires a plan document, and once plan assets pass $250,000 you file Form 5500-EZ each year by July 31. That form is short, but it is a deadline you have to remember, and missing it carries a penalty of $250 a day up to $150,000. If you hate administrative chores and you save modest amounts anyway, the SIMPLE IRA's simplicity is a real benefit, not a consolation prize. Plenty of people choose the plan they will actually maintain over the plan that looks best in a spreadsheet.

Timing rules add one more wrinkle. A solo 401k must be established by December 31 of the tax year, though employer contributions can wait until your filing deadline with extensions. A SIMPLE IRA must be set up by October 1 of the year you want it to cover, which is earlier than most people expect. If you are reading this in November and hoping to shelter this year's income in a new SIMPLE IRA, you have missed that window. The solo 401k window is still open, though your deferral election has to be in place by December 31. That calendar difference alone has decided more than one plan choice I have seen discussed.

One question I am leaving open, because the honest answer depends on facts I do not have for you: what happens when your business grows past the owner-only stage? If you plan to hire within two years, starting a solo 401k now and converting later is fine, but it is a conversion you will have to manage. If hiring is already on this year's agenda, starting with a SIMPLE IRA or a regular 401k saves a transition. Ask yourself which future is more likely, not which plan sounds better in the abstract, and pick for that future.

Try it. Compare what each plan lets you shelter on your own income before you choose. Run the free solo 401k vs SEP IRA calculator

Frequently asked questions

Is a solo 401k better than a SIMPLE IRA for self employed workers?

Usually yes for owner-only businesses, because the solo 401k allows a $24,500 employee deferral plus employer profit sharing up to $72,000 combined in 2026, versus a $17,000 SIMPLE IRA deferral.

Can a self employed person with employees use a solo 401k?

No, except for a spouse who works in the business. Once you have eligible employees, a solo 401k no longer fits and a SIMPLE IRA or regular 401k is the usual route.

Does a SIMPLE IRA allow Roth contributions?

No. SIMPLE IRA contributions are pre-tax. A solo 401k allows employee deferrals to be designated Roth.

Can you have a SIMPLE IRA and a solo 401k in the same year?

No. An employer cannot maintain a SIMPLE IRA and a 401k in the same calendar year. A mid-year switch is possible under SECURE 2.0, with the SIMPLE plan ending by September 30 and the 401k starting October 1.

Which plan is simpler to run?

The SIMPLE IRA. It has almost no annual filing, while a solo 401k may require Form 5500-EZ once plan assets pass $250,000.

Related: Solo 401k Contribution Limits 2026 · What Happens When You Hire Employees · Solo 401k Roth vs Traditional

One note a month: subscribe to the newsletter.